Skip to main content

Analysing West Ham: have the Hammers struck lucky with their transfers this summer?

West Ham, after an uncertain start, are currently one of the biggest talking points of the opening 2017/18 transfer window. After the early bosman transfer of Pablo Zabaleta there was a lull until the last few days, where the Hammers have signed Javier Hernández, Marko Arnautović on permanent deals as well as England’s current number one, Joe Hart on a loan deal from Manchester City. On paper, these are strong signings – Chicharito in particular being touted as a bargain in the current transfer climate, especially when you compare Middlesbrough paying just £1 million less for Britt Assombalonga. Ultimately though, fantasy football isn’t played on paper but rather your computer screens and the football pitch. Will these players be worth the money when the season starts? FFSpy aims to find out.

Joe Hart – Value: 4.5 – Previous season score (15/16): 134


Joe Hart arrives at West Ham with a chip on his shoulder. Ousted by Pep soon after the manager joining Manchester City due to his perceived lack of ability to play out from the back, Hart was shipped off to Torino for the 16/17 season, where statistically he struggled, keeping only 5 clean sheets with an average save rate of 2.53 a game. This from a fantasy football perspective is not great, but Hart had a very successful six seasons at the Citizens and his last season in the Premier League kept 15 clean sheets in 35 games with an average save rate of 1.91 a game.

You could read this and feel sympathy for Hart, clearly playing behind a weaker defence than he did in Torino than he did Manchester, with his shot interaction being significantly higher. However, he was just as much a problem as he was a solution at Torino, with 5 errors leading to goals and 7 to shots. This doesn’t bode well and it could be evidence that his infamous mistake against Iceland at Euro 2016 followed him to Italy.

Nonetheless, you are here to decide whether he should go in your squad or not. I personally believe at this time, Joe Hart isn’t worth it. West Ham’s opening three are tricky – three away games was never going to be easy, but take into account the fact that they are playing a revitalised Manchester United if pre-season is to go by, a fairly uniform Southampton team and a Rafa Benitez lead Newcastle squad and there is every reason to doubt. Will he keep a clean sheet in any of those games? Against Southampton or Newcastle there is a chance and if he does, he certainly would have earnt it.

The verdict: Fixture wise, there is better available but Hart has a very strong record in the league that is much more impressive than many of the 4.5 picks.

Marko Arnautović – Value: 7.0 – Previous season score (16/17): 117


Last season, the former Stoke playmaker would have disappointed many a fantasy football pundit: 117 points from his final value of 7.1 isn’t the greatest return when you look back at previous bargains from yesteryear. 15/16 was a fairly decent haul with 11 goals and 6 assists and the Hammers will be hoping for these kind of numbers or more from their record signing.

Statistically, Arnautovic isn’t too bad. In comparison to Tadic, Willian and Zaha he doesn’t top anything, but he isn’t bottom of anything except passing accuracy. You can view this in a number of ways: He isn’t a good passer of the ball, he passes less/more than his counterparts or he tries numerous risky passes (hence a key pass rate per game of 1.6)

Fails to top any statistic, but isn't particular bad in any either. Source: whoscored.com


In spite of these mediocre stats, there is potential for Arnautovic to slot into your team this season. The 7.0 million range is a strange one this year, nobody really stands out for me so far in pre-season bar Willian, who could be a great pick up with Hazard nursing an ankle injury and Pedro currently being treated for multiple facial fractures. As record signings go, they tend to start and with an increasingly exciting West Ham strike force forming with Arnautovic, Lanzini and Antonio in behind Hernández, Arnautovic could be a unique way into this forward line, with I believe many people looking at the Chicarito and Lanzini as potential West Ham picks. Don’t count him out just yet.

The verdict: See how he performs pre-season and in the first few games. Realistically, Lanzini is a better pick to start as he will be the focal point of the Hammers attack, so I would avoid for now.

Javier Hernández – Value: 7.0 – Highest previous season score (10/11): 110


Seven million. Seven. Million. FPL have thrown a massive curveball into the player valuations by potentially overpricing many strikers in the mid-tier teams but little pea represents real value for money initially. The Mexican leaves Leverkusen with a 1 in 2 record, and it only gets better – Chicharito has the seventh highest goals per minutes ratio in Premier League history. So what’s the catch?

I don’t think there is one! At the moment, I can’t see why most people wouldn’t choose him barring budgets. If anything, he could even be your second choice striker, allowing your budget to spread across much stronger players in midfield or defence. Competition in the price range is minimal, I believe currently it will be between him, one of the Southampton forwards Gabbiadini or Austin and then maybe Deeney. Dwight Gayle is a popular pick in this price range too, but unproven in the top tier.

In summary, I would say he is a must pick right now. If you can fit him in as your third striker, you are very top heavy, but would have a lethal three. As a second pick striker, he opens up a great amount of budget for the rest of your team. He has a proven record in the Premier League and he is joining a team that looks fantastic on paper. The only downfalls are that everyone should have him, so he is certainly not a differential at this stage and that initial fixtures could be seen as tricky, but a debut against his former club screams 90th minute winner.


The verdict: Get the Mexican straight into your team if you can.

Comments